Dorothy Allison’s “Bastard out of Carolina” is one of the best books that I have read in awhile. It is very hard for me to “love” a book, but Allison’s style and realness really grabs my attention. Books that deal with real issues that really delve into the topic really grab my attention, especially sensitive issues such as the abuse that Bone experienced.
Bone was a very intelligent and experienced person for such a young girl. Bone knew a lot of things that most people do not know about until they are much older. Bone’s family and surrounding environment were very honest with whatever was going on in their lives, especially the struggle they went through just to get by. Bone’s family’s financial situation was very bad, and always was her whole life, and she had to experience things that most children do not usually have to go through. I feel that this was the main reason that Bone knew more than most children her age know. Her mother, Anney, was very honest with her, and always let Bone know what was going on whether it was about their financial status or about the health of their family members. They had a big extended family, and all of the members of the family were in the same boat financially.
One main flaw that I have with Anney is her constant need for a man in her life. Anney had Bone at a younger age than most woman plan on having children, and does not even keep in touch with Bone’s father. Anney continues to fill this void of a man in her life, I think, for financial security. However, the men that Anney brings home are never good, and she is much better off without them. More specifically, is Anney’s brother’s friend, Glen. Glen and Anney eventually got married after a little time together, which was one of the biggest mistakes Anney could have made. I am not sure if Anney is aware of the sexual abuse that Glen imposes on Bone, but I feel it is impossible as a mother not to know when something is going on with your child. Anney is a good mother to Bone, and this is why I feel she must not know exactly what is bothering her daughter, because she is always looking out for the best thing for Bone. One main reason besides money that I think Anney stays with Glen is because she knows that he could make Bone’s birth certificate official since he eventually takes over both Bone and Reese’s custody as a father. Dorothy Allison was very descriptive when it came to explaining the abuse that Bone experienced, which added to the realness. So far, Bone has experienced not only too much mentally that most children her age do not have to experience, but also physically. The physical abuse that Glen performs on Bone is absolutely disgusting and disturbing to think that someone who is supposed to be a “father figure” could ever do something like this to anyone, especially a “daughter.” This was a very different perspective of the southern lifestyle, but I do not feel the actions had anything to do with the location of where they live. I feel that an experience such as this could occur anywhere; in the north, south, west or east. I do not think Allison’s intentions were to exactly tear apart the south as a whole with this example of them living in the south, but it was interesting to see Allison’s connections to southern lifestyle. Clearly, Glen is not the ordinary southern gentlemen, nor was he rich, nor did he own slaves, or anything of that matter.
I feel that Dorothy Allison’s “Bastard out of Carolina” is, so far, a great book that tells of the realness of a child’s experience growing up in the south with little money. I feel that due to the amount of negative things that took place in Bone’s young life, there is only hope for goodness in the future. I am hoping that by the duration of this novel, Bone will be happy and successful in her future endeavors.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
I also think that this book is really excellent, and I just wanted to keep reading. Anyways, while reading this I was kind of angry at Anney for staying with Glen after she knew what had happened to Bone. After reading your blog though I can see that she didn't only do it for herself, but for her girls too. I think that they would have just been better off alone right from the start, I think Anney only had good intentions. She wanted for Bone to get the red stamp off of her birth certificate. For some reason she thought that was such a big deal. She didn't want her little girl to be labeled like that and by Glen being her Daddy that could be fixed. He was also a man and a father figure in the girl's lives which I'm sure Anney thought was important for many reasons.
Kathryn,
As you have discussed, Bone is a very mature individual for her age because of all that she has been through and experienced. I know personally that I was not as aware of my surroundings and was not as observant as Bone at her age. It is almost as if her childhood has been taken away or has been stolen from her, by the environment in which she lives. As a result, her innocence has melted away at a very early age as well. I do agree that Anney’s family, along with Anney herself, are very honest and open with Bone about the situation around them, however I feel that by Bone experiencing physical abuse and sexual assault it has kind of opened her eyes. She is able to see the evil that exists in society and life, the evil that exists even within some people that many just overlook. I also find it interesting that you talk about how soon Anney marries Glen after she meets him. I definitely agree that she feels that he will provide her with a financial stability; however I do not understand how she could jump into the marriage so quickly. I know that personally I would have to know a man for quite a while before marrying him. I also feel that if I had two daughters, I would wait even longer in order to ensure that he would be good to them and that he would be a good addition to their lives as well, not just my own. I feel that this is the largest mistake that Anney makes throughout the novel, and therefore is responsible for the “negative things in Bone’s life” that you talk about.
I agree, I really enjoy reading this book so far. I do not really care for Anney as a character. She is not a great mother, or person for that matter. She might have good intentions to get rid of Glen and make her daughter have a "normal life again, but she might not know exactly how to go about it, or know if its right to do it. I feel sorry for Bone. She is a young child, and she is so angry, and depressed. It's sad.
Post a Comment